US Department of Labor released RCT results for 2 DOL-funded "Pay for Success" projects - Roca (in MA) for justice-involved young men, & Center for Employment Opportunities (in NY) for adult parolees. Quick take: No impacts (yet) on recidivism or employment; the RCTs are ongoing.

Programs:

  • Roca - the Massachusetts project - is a 4-year program for young male parolees & probationers. It seeks to foster strong relationships with program staff to change destructive thinking patterns, & provides transitional employment & workforce training.  

  • Center for Employment Opportunities (CEO), the NY project, is a 4-6 month program for high-risk adult parolees just released from prison. It provides training in life skills & work readiness, paid transitional employment, job placement assistance, & post-employment follow-up.

  • Under the Pay for Success (PFS) funding model, private investors (e.g., Goldman Sachs, philanthropic foundations) pay for program delivery, & get repaid by gov't - possibly with a return - only if the program achieves specific, pre-specified results as verified thru evaluation.

Study Design:

  • DOL to its credit required *rigorous* evaluations - resulting in sizable RCTs of both programs. The Roca RCT recruited a sample of 991 young men in 2014-15; the CEO RCT recruited a sample of 2,357 adult parolees from late 2013-2015.

Findings:

  • Unfortunately, interim findings of both RCTs (avg of 1.5-2 yrs after study entry for Roca, and >1y for CEO) show near-zero impact on the targeted outcomes: days individuals were sentenced to incarceration, & employment rate. So, per the PFS model, investors weren't repaid.

  • But both projects & RCTs are continuing, in hope that impacts will materialize with larger samples & longer follow-up.

Comment:

  • Frustratingly, DOL's report only provides high-level details on the RCTs, not enough to gauge study quality; hopefully someone will release a full report.

  • Here's a link to the DOL report. Disclosure: my former employer, the Laura & John Arnold Foundation, invested in both PFS projects & is helping fund the Roca RCT.

We use cookies to improve your experience and to help us understand how you use our site. Please refer to our cookie notice and privacy statement for more information regarding cookies and other third-party tracking that may be enabled.

Intuit Mailchimp logo